Frankfurt cases (also known as Frankfurt counterexamples or Frankfurt-style cases) were presented by philosopher Harry Frankfurt in 1969 as counterexamples to the principle of alternate possibilities (PAP), which holds that an agent is morally responsible for an action only if that person could have done … See more The principle of alternate possibilities (PAP) forms part of an influential argument for the incompatibility of responsibility and causal determinism, often called the core argument for incompatibilism. This argument is … See more There have been a number of responses to the two-horned dilemma. One response has been to argue that a deterministic connection does … See more • Kadri Vihvelin. Edward N. Zalta (ed.). "Arguments for Incompatibilism". The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Spring 2011 ed.). See more From the PAP definition "a person is morally responsible for what he has done only if he could have done otherwise", Frankfurt infers that a person is not morally responsible … See more One of the first objections raised by opponents of the Frankfurt-style cases is the two-horned dilemma. This objection was most notably … See more The responses to the Frankfurt cases are still being debated. It remains to be seen whether critics can successfully show that Frankfurt cases fail. See more WebThis sort of case—a Frankfurt-style case—appears to threaten PAP. Although PAP has traditionally been accepted by both compatibilists and incompatibilists about causal …

The Frankfurt Cases: The Moral of the Stories The …

WebMar 10, 2024 · This paper argues that Frankfurt-style counterexamples do not compromise the agent’s ability to decide otherwise. In his attack on the Principle of Alternative Possibilities, Frankfurt relied on what Austin called the ‘all-in’ sense of ‘can’, and misconstrued the agent’s inability to do otherwise as an all-in can’t. WebWhite & Case LLP. Bockenheimer Landstraße 20. 60323 Frankfurt am Main. Germany. +49 69 29994 0. +49 69 29994 1444. red color poem

Frankfurt Cases and Overdetermination Canadian Journal of …

WebJul 9, 2024 · Moral Responsibility and the Principle of Alternative Possibilities. 1. Background. Like most important philosophical claims, PAP is more complex than it first … WebFrankfurt cases are strongly disanalogous to physical determinism. In a Frankfurt case, the person's action is not determined by any actual physical laws. The sense in which the … WebThe Frankfurt Cases are a set of four fictitious situations that examine the concept of determinism, or the assumption that every action is predestined by outside forces. Each time, despite the fact that the protagonist's actions were predestined by an outside factor, they were nevertheless morally held accountable. knighterrant cleaning armor